Friday, October 3, 2008

Politics and Sensibility: More on Morgan


Sex Politics and Sensibility: More on Morgan
by Kristen Loveland

Robin Morgan wrote an anti-Palin piece a couple of days ago entitled, "When Sisterhood is Suicide," which initiated a debate both on Girl with Pen between Deborah and Courtney, and at Feministing between Deborah, Courtney, and the wide feminist world. Deborah loved the content of the piece, but Courtney argued that its sarcastic, snarky tone was alienating. First, let me say that tone matters. I watched the debates last night in a Brooklyn bar with nary a McCain supporter in sight. In that setting there wasn't a doubt about it: Biden won. He was calm, substantive, and authoritative in his knowledge, and never once attacked Palin personally. The Brooklyn crowd laughed at Palin's folksky "darn its." "Gosh darnit gee golly joe," mocked the guy at the end of the bar. Folksy and "nice" and not snarky, Palin's tone may have been endearing to some crowds, but it wasn't to mine.

So tone matters-- but audience matters more. Who was Robin Morgan addressing in her piece? I didn't get the sense that she was trying to reach across the aisle, that this was the opening salvo in a conversation that would end with some congenial beers at the local bar between Morgan and Joe Hockey Mom McSixpack. This is Robin Morgan, after all.

I don't even think she's talking to a younger generation of feminists, to my generation. Here's why:
Sure, we wanted to vote for the right woman. Sure, we’ll have to wait a bit longer for her. Meanwhile, in Obama we can have a chief executive who reflects our politics, and who—especially since he may have both houses of Congress behind him—just might turn out to be one hell of a great president.

and:
Do not cut off your womb to spite the Democrats. (Also do not sit this election out or play write-in-vote games. And tempting though it may seem, do not blow a vote for the Green Party.)

Morgan sure is rabble-rousing, but she's rabble-rousing to a generation that came of feminist age in the '70s, when the sides were more clearly cut ("us" vs. "the patriarchy"), to whom such angry, snarky speech will hardly be unusual or unwelcome, and who embody the imagined fears of Democrats everywhere. But are these fears real? I've yet to meet a Hillary supporter who has said she will vote for the Green party, or God forbid, Palin, because Hillary didn't get the nom. As a young feminist who is cocooned within a certain generational worldview, I'd really like to know if this phenomenon does exist. And if it does, please watch this.

What I found most effective about Morgan's piece was that she destroys her mantra: Sisterhood is powerful. Sisterhood, after all, is very much a straw man that ignores the realities of how fractured the idea of "woman" is. It's all in her title: When Sisterhood is Suicide. The 1970s idea that all could be solved through coming together and sisterhood ends up being as cynical an idea as McCain thinking he could net a bunch of Hillary supporters by choosing a Woman as VP. First, we realized that there exist racial, sexuality, and economic issues that cannot be brushed under the rug in the name of sisterhood. Now, we realize that there are ideological and policy issues--the right to our bodies, the right to an experienced Vice Presidential candidate--that cannot be ignored in the name of sisterhood.

So is Morgan's rant destructive? Yes. But is it alienating? Well, it won't do much for my generation of feminists, who prefer a more conciliatory and reasoned tone. Then again, there's never been much fear that we're heading the Palin way. And some conservative commentators might love to wave this piece around as evidence that those crazy Feminazis are at it again and don't understand Palin's version of "nice," non-pay-equity, non-choice feminism. But if it does stay within its intended audience, then it could be very effective.

Of course, given the internet, the chance of it hitting only its intended crowd is... next to none.

18 comments:

Deborah Siegel said...

Kristen, I so appreciate your POV! Thank you for clarifying some of the reasons Morgan's piece felt alienating. It was interesting to me to read the comments over at feministing too -- I'm off to post your link over there...

Courtney said...

What she said!
Thanks Kristen. You put it far more eloquently than I.

Kristen said...

Hey you two, thanks for starting the conversation. It's a great one to have-- What is after all, the best way to approach the question of the Palin?

Bob Lamm said...

I have no idea how many Clinton supporters around the U.S. plan to vote for McCain or at least NOT for Obama. But I had a very disturbing conversation about this with one friend, a feminist in her 30s, who was talking about voting Green and made it clear she would not vote for Obama for president. So I can say that this appears to be a genuine issue.

Bob Lamm said...

I should add: my friend was VERY passionate in her support for Hillary Clinton and very bitter that Obama was taking away a nomination that belonged to Clinton.

Unknown said...

This is a great article. It gave me a lot of useful information. thank you very much.
Signature:
Jugar juegos de frozen en línea gratis, los nuevos de princesa de Disney juegos frozen - la princesa encantadora y linda. Divertirse frozen!

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing. I hope it will be helpful for too many people that are searching for this topic.
Signature:
download descargar facebook gratis para Android celular and download free descargar facebook apk and descargar facebook gratis , descarga facebook

Unknown said...

You have some very interesting and informative post like this.
Thanks for sharing!
Hajj 2017 packages

Drag Racer V3 said...

Great post. I really like it friv4schoolonline.net

alicetaylor said...

great article, I was very impressed about it, wish you would have stayed next share

potaup

Kavita Sharma said...

We would like to express our gratitude to all visitors who took the time to visit our official site of Lucknow Escorts. Our escort agency in Lucknow is a pioneer in the escort business and has set benchmarks for other escort specialist co-op all through India. We work through the site as well as through a quick email or visit assist work area with welling. Our Lucknow Escort Services are unmatched and unbeaten.

Riya Rai said...

Our Dwarka Escorts call girl, is high professionalism, dependability, reliability to offer such sexual relations that you cannot fail to remember. If a decent sex experience is a thing that you need hire Escorts in Dwarka for full fulfillment.

Bed Pari Bangalore Escorts said...


Thanks for sharing this brilliant article it was a very useful and helpful article.

premier escorts bangalore
Escorts in RT Nagar
escorts services in bannerghatta
escorts in koramangala
hoskote escorts
bellandur escorts
Call Girls in Bangalore
Bangalore Independent Escorts

My Site said...

This is a good tip particularly to those fresh to the blogosphere. Brief but very accurate information… Many thanks for sharing this one. A must read post!
토토사이트
온라인경마

My Site said...

It’s difficult to find experienced people in this particular topic, but you seem like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks
racesitepro3
racesitepro3
racesitepro3
racesite

John Hardy said...

This article give ma a lot of information about politics. I really love it. Thanks for sharing this article. Now it's time to avail HALFCASTE CREAM SET for more information.

Gary sobers said...

I was searching to read that kind of article and I finally found it. I read your blog and I find it very informative. This post is interesting. Now its time to avail roller shutter repairs for more information.

Mobile app development company said...

Nice post. Thanks for sharing with us. I want to share information about the Healthcare App Development Company in Pune | Appconsultio. Welcome to our premier Healthcare App Development Company in Pune, where the synergy of innovation and compassion is reshaping the digital health solutions landscape. As a forward-thinking and client-centric organization, we take immense pride in our expertise in creating state-of-the-art mobile applications, meticulously designed to transform the healthcare experience.